Concerns Over Kenya’s Competency-Based Curriculum Implementation

Kenya’s ambitious shift from the long-standing 8-4-4 education system to the Competency-Based Curriculum (CBC) is facing mounting scrutiny as the first cohort of Grade 9 learners prepares for the pivotal transition to senior school and the selection of career pathways. This significant educational reform, intended to cultivate practical skills and competencies for the 21st century, has been met with growing apprehension from parents and the general public. Key concerns center on the readiness of schools to accommodate the new curriculum, particularly regarding infrastructure and resources, the preparedness and training of teachers to effectively deliver the competency-based approach, and the escalating financial burden placed on families to support their children’s learning. The lack of clear communication about the structure of senior school pathways and the specializations offered by different institutions has further amplified anxieties, leaving many stakeholders uncertain about the future direction of their children’s education.

A Report by NTV Kenya

A deeper examination reveals a multitude of specific challenges hindering the smooth implementation of the CBC, especially as it enters the senior school phase. Many public schools grapple with inadequate infrastructure, including classrooms and essential laboratories for STEM-related subjects, raising doubts about their capacity to effectively deliver the curriculum. Teachers, while some have received training, often feel ill-prepared for the hands-on, skill-based learning methodologies required by the CBC, particularly within the specialized senior school pathways. The financial strain on parents continues to be a major point of contention, with the costs of specialized learning materials and project-based assessments adding to the already significant expenses of education. Furthermore, the early specialization inherent in the CBC, with learners choosing career pathways at the end of Grade 9, has sparked concerns about potentially limiting future opportunities if these choices are not well-informed. The availability and quality of guidance and counseling to support learners in making these crucial decisions are also under question, with fears that inadequate support could lead to misaligned choices and unfulfilled potential.

A Report about Pathways to Senior School by NTV Kenya

In response to these widespread concerns, the Kenyan government has acknowledged the challenges and outlined various initiatives aimed at addressing them, including policy statements, transition guidelines, and teacher training programs . However, expert analyses consistently point to persistent issues such as inadequate teacher training, limited resources and infrastructure, financial burdens on families, and policy coordination challenges . Recommendations from education experts emphasize the need for enhanced and continuous teacher training, prioritized allocation of resources, effective engagement with parents and stakeholders, and sustained investment in school infrastructure . As the country navigates this critical juncture in its educational transformation, addressing these multifaceted concerns will be paramount to ensuring the successful implementation of the CBC and realizing its intended benefits for Kenyan learners .  

References:

Nation Grade 9 learners to choose senior school pathways in second term

Nation CBC: What parents and stakeholders want in transition to senior school

The Standard Maths no longer compulsory as CBC pioneers set to pick careers

The Standard Concerns over transition of Grade 9 learners to senior secondary school

Citizen Digital Wananchi Opinion: Why many are moving kids to International Schools

Importance of Stakeholder Engagement in Kenya’s CBC Rollout

As the countdown to January 6, 2025, continues, the challenges of transitioning Grade 9 learners under Kenya’s Competency-Based Curriculum (CBC) remain pressing but not insurmountable. Choosing this moment to abandon the CBC would only deepen the disruption experienced throughout the education sector. Instead, it is crucial to address the systemic gaps that currently hinder the curriculum’s success. Paramount to these efforts is the need for timely and transparent disbursement of the KSh 15.3 billion allocated for infrastructure and resources. Schools must complete critical projects to accommodate the new cohort of learners adequately. Simultaneously, a renewed focus on teacher training is vital; educators must be equipped with the skills necessary to deliver the CBC effectively. Without this commitment to human capital development, the curriculum risks becoming little more than policy rhetoric.

KTN Report

Parents and communities play a pivotal role in this transition, serving as essential stakeholders in the education process. It is crucial for parents to actively engage with schools and view educational reforms as a shared responsibility. As the saying goes, “if you think education is expensive, try ignorance,” underscoring the importance of investing in future generations. Therefore, parents must participate actively, even amidst holiday distractions, by supporting their children’s learning journey. Local leaders and non-governmental organizations can support these efforts by leveraging resources and providing technical expertise where needed, especially in marginalized areas. A community-driven approach is key to ensuring a sustainable and inclusive rollout that benefits all learners.

On a broader scale, Kenya must critically evaluate its approach to educational reform. Drawing insights from successful models, like Finland’s competency-based education, can offer valuable guidance. However, these insights must be adapted meaningfully to reflect Kenya’s socio-economic realities. Developing tailored solutions requires engaging educators, parents, and learners in the reform process, creating a curriculum that resonates with the nation’s specific needs. As Kenya progresses, the necessary shift from short-term fixes to a comprehensive and holistic educational strategy, encompassing infrastructure, teacher training, and curriculum development, will be vital. Addressing these foundational issues will allow the CBC to transform into a tool for equitable and effective education. The upcoming January transition presents a crucial opportunity for Kenya to reaffirm its commitment to educational excellence and establish a solid foundation for its learners’ futures.

References:

Nation Grade 9: Staring at a crisis

Kenyans.co.ke Education Ministry Ready for Grade 9 Transition

Nation Move swiftly to avert looming Grade 9 crisis

The Standard 50 days to Grade 9 rollout: Are schools ready for CBC transition?

The Kenya Times Govt Addresses Looming Crisis in Schools Ahead of Reopening

The Star Ruto: We’re ready for Grade 9 transition in 2025

Nation Ruto says government is ready for Grade 9, but reality on the ground is different

Nation Why Grade 9 roll-out could be chaotic for schools

Kenya News Agency Kenya-Finland strategizes on CBC implementation

The Star Finland partners with Kenya to enhance CBC

Challenges Facing Kenya’s Grade 9 Education Transition

With less than a month before Grade 9 learners resume studies on January 6, 2025, the readiness of Kenya’s education system remains a significant concern. Many schools are struggling with infrastructural challenges, with some yet to begin construction of new classrooms, while others lag behind schedule. This delay has been compounded by the government’s slow disbursement of funds to support the transition. Even where construction is underway, reports of shoddy workmanship have emerged as contractors, working on tight budgets or without funds, race against time. These logistical shortcomings have left education stakeholders, including parents and teachers, questioning the feasibility of a smooth transition to the final stage of Junior Secondary School (JSS). Staffing shortages have also compounded the problem, as the recruitment of 46,000 teachers since 2023 has barely scratched the surface of the human resource needs in schools under the Competency-Based Curriculum (CBC).

Citizen Digital Report

The issues plaguing the Grade 9 rollout reflect broader systemic challenges inherent in implementing CBC. Since its introduction, CBC has faced criticism over inadequate preparation and a lack of alignment with local realities. Kenya’s model has largely drawn inspiration from foreign systems, particularly Finland’s acclaimed competency-based education, yet it lacks the supportive structures that underpin success in such contexts. Finland’s achievements are rooted in a robust system of teacher training, well-equipped facilities, and motivated educators, elements that remain weak or absent in Kenya’s education landscape. Sub-Saharan Africa’s broader experience with competency-based curricula offers cautionary lessons. In countries like Tanzania, Rwanda, and Zambia, the transition to CBC has been marred by poor understanding among teachers, inadequate training, and insufficient resources. Many educators in these regions have reverted to traditional teaching methods, highlighting the gap between lofty aspirations and ground realities.

The parallels are striking. Kenya’s educators face similar challenges, with a significant proportion lacking the training needed to implement CBC effectively. Parents, too, have expressed frustration with what they perceive as a rushed and poorly communicated rollout. Meanwhile, resource constraints remain a glaring issue, leaving many schools ill-equipped to handle the transition. The lessons from other African nations emphasize the dangers of importing education systems without tailoring them to local needs. In Kenya, just as in Zambia, Rwanda, and Tanzania, teachers struggle to adapt to a curriculum designed for contexts vastly different from their own. While the government continues to assure stakeholders that CBC will transform the country’s education system, the reality on the ground suggests that urgent interventions are needed to avert chaos when Grade 9 resumes.

References:

Nation Grade 9: Staring at a crisis

Kenyans.co.ke Education Ministry Ready for Grade 9 Transition

Nation Move swiftly to avert looming Grade 9 crisis

The Standard 50 days to Grade 9 rollout: Are schools ready for CBC transition?

The Kenya Times Govt Addresses Looming Crisis in Schools Ahead of Reopening

The Star Ruto: We’re ready for Grade 9 transition in 2025

Nation Ruto says government is ready for Grade 9, but reality on the ground is different

Nation Why Grade 9 roll-out could be chaotic for schools

Kenya News Agency Kenya-Finland strategizes on CBC implementation

The Star Finland partners with Kenya to enhance CBC