Kenya’s Political Landscape: Ruto’s Surprising Move and Good Governance Challenges

Kenya’s President Ruto has taken a surprising step by nominating four Cabinet Secretaries from the opposition party, sparking concerns about the legitimacy of his administration. The move comes as the country grapples with economic challenges and political tensions.

Left: Raila Odinga; Right: President Ruto

Sources close to the ruling party have revealed that the nominations were made without the formal approval of the opposition leader, Raila Odinga, who had previously issued demands for specific issues to be addressed before engaging in dialogue with the government. This development has left many wondering whether the opposition is quietly aligning itself with the government, potentially compromising its independence.

As the situation unfolds, analysts are cautioning that a broad-based government of national unity could have far-reaching implications for Kenya’s democracy. In light of this, it is crucial to examine the concept of good governance and its intersection with human rights. Good governance refers to the process by which public institutions conduct public affairs, manage public resources, and guarantee the realization of human rights in a manner free from abuse and corruption. This requires respecting human rights, ensuring transparency, accountability, responsibility, participatory decision-making, responsiveness to people’s needs, and freedom from corruption.

According to experts, good governance is closely linked to human rights, as human rights standards and principles provide a set of values to guide government actions and a framework for accountability. In turn, good governance is essential for respecting and protecting human rights in a sustainable manner.

The four key areas where good governance and human rights intersect are:

  1. Democratic Institutions: The establishment of strong democratic institutions is critical for ensuring that power is exercised transparently and in accordance with the rule of law.
  2. Public Service Delivery: Good governance requires effective public service delivery, which involves providing essential services to citizens in a fair, equitable, and efficient manner.
  3. The Rule of Law: The rule of law is essential for upholding human rights, as it provides a framework for ensuring that laws are respected and enforced fairly and without discrimination.
  4. Anti-Corruption Efforts: Anti-corruption efforts are vital for preventing the abuse of power and ensuring that public resources are used for the benefit of all citizens.

As Kenya’s government navigates this complex landscape, it is essential to prioritize good governance and ensure that institutions are accountable, transparent, and responsive to the needs of the people. This requires a commitment to upholding human rights, protecting fundamental freedoms, and promoting sustainable development.

References:

The Standard Mixed reactions as Ruto unveils new Cabinet

AllAfrica Kenya: Sifuna Insists ODM Not in Govt Despite Ruto’s Cabinet Picks

AllAfrica Kenya: Ruto Co-Opts ODM Into Govt Naming Joho, Oparanya, Mbadi In Cabinet

Associated Press Kenyan president appoints opposition ministers to his Cabinet amid political unrest

United Nations Human Rights About good governance

United Nations Human Rights OHCHR and good governance

Navigating Change: The Path Ahead for Kenya’s Acting Inspector General of Police

The Kenyan Police Service stands at a crossroads, facing both challenges and opportunities as it enters a new chapter under Acting Inspector General Douglas Kanja. Kanja’s appointment follows the resignation of Japhet Koome, whose tenure was marked by controversy, particularly surrounding the handling of recent anti-government protests.

Former Inspector General of Police – Japhet Koome

Koome took office in November 2022, bringing with him 31 years of experience within the force. He had previously served as Nairobi County Police Commander and Commandant of the National Police Service College in Kiganjo. His appointment was meant to bring stability and reform after a period of political turbulence and public distrust in law enforcement. However, his time in office was overshadowed by escalating tensions between citizens and authorities, fueled by President Ruto’s administration’s introduction of controversial tax hikes.

The protests that erupted in response were met with a heavy-handed police response, resulting in at least 39 deaths according to Kenya’s national rights watchdog. This sparked widespread condemnation both domestically and internationally, with accusations of excessive force and human rights violations leveled against the police. Public outcry intensified, leading to calls for Koome’s resignation and an overhaul of the police force. While President Ruto initially dismissed the protesters, mounting pressure forced him to concede, ultimately accepting Koome’s resignation on July 12th, 2024 and appointing Kanja as Acting Inspector General.

The situation highlights several deeply rooted issues within Kenya: the ever-present struggle for economic justice, concerns over government transparency and accountability, and a history of police brutality that continues to erode public trust. Kanja now faces the daunting task of restoring faith in the police service while addressing these fundamental challenges. His success will depend on his ability to implement meaningful reforms, promote human rights, and build bridges between law enforcement and the communities they serve.

Acting Inspector General of Police – Douglas Kanja

Looking ahead, Kanja’s leadership presents an opportunity for positive change within the Kenyan Police Service. He can prioritize de-escalation tactics during protests, strengthen internal oversight mechanisms to ensure accountability, and invest in community policing initiatives that foster trust and collaboration. It is crucial for him to engage with civil society organizations, human rights groups, and ordinary citizens to understand their concerns and work together towards a more just and equitable society. The road ahead will undoubtedly be challenging, but with commitment, transparency, and a genuine desire to serve the people, Kanja can pave the way for a more effective and ethical police force in Kenya.

References:

Citizen Digital Japhet Koome Sworn In As New Inspector General Of Police

The Star 8 police bosses shortlisted for Deputy Inspector General position

Aljazeera Kenya police chief resigns after criticism over protest crackdown

The Star Police boss IG Japhet Koome resigns

Kenya Kwanza Legal Challenges: Impact on Economic Transformation

President William Ruto’s Kenya Kwanza administration has faced a series of legal challenges that have impeded the implementation of the Bottom-Up Economic Transformation Agenda. In January 2024, the High Court issued an injunction against Ruto’s proposal to deploy police officers to Haiti to combat gang violence, declaring the initiative unconstitutional. The judiciary underscored that there was no legal basis for sending police abroad instead of military personnel, granting the government a 14-day window to file an appeal. This ruling exemplifies the judiciary’s stringent oversight of the executive’s international commitments.

In February 2024, another judicial setback occurred when the court enjoined the funding for a pet housing project, integral to Ruto’s broader affordable housing initiative. The court found the funding mechanism incompatible with constitutional mandates, thus stymying Ruto’s flagship program aimed at alleviating housing shortages. This judgment highlighted the judiciary’s rigorous interpretation of constitutional provisions governing public expenditure and developmental projects, reinforcing the legal scrutiny applied to executive actions.

These judicial rebuffs are part of an ongoing trend where the courts have systematically invalidated various projects and proposals under the Kenya Kwanza agenda. The recurrent legal impediments have substantially hampered the administration’s capacity to implement its strategic plans, underscoring the judiciary’s crucial role in shaping public policy and governance in Kenya. These legal confrontations illustrate the persistent tension between the executive and the judiciary, as Ruto’s administration navigates the intricate constitutional and legal landscape to advance its ambitious policy objectives.

References:

Nation Blocked: Ruto’s never-ending losing streak in court

BBC How Kenya’s judges stood up to President William Ruto

Global Initiative Kenya’s High Court blocks proposal to send police support to Haiti

BBC Kenya housing levy: Blow to William Ruto as court blocks tax

The EastAfrican Ruto furious after court blocks funding for pet housing project

Balancing IMF Demands: Kenya’s Economic Challenges and Public Unrest

Kenya’s relationship with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has been a contentious topic, especially due to the economic conditions tied to IMF loans that impact ordinary Kenyans. The tension has escalated recently with protests against tax hikes, which many Kenyans view as a direct consequence of the IMF’s conditions. This unrest highlights the public’s frustration with both the government’s economic policies and the IMF’s role in shaping them. The IMF’s involvement in Kenya is seen as a double-edged sword; while it provides necessary financial assistance, it also imposes stringent conditions that many feel exacerbate economic inequality and hardship. Public outcry has particularly focused on how these conditions seem to undermine national sovereignty, with citizens questioning the long-term implications for Kenya’s economic independence.

The IMF has a long history of providing financial assistance to Kenya, most recently through a $2.34 billion arrangement aimed at supporting economic recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic, addressing debt vulnerabilities, and fostering inclusive growth. However, the stringent conditions attached, including austerity measures and increased taxes, have been deeply unpopular. The proposed Finance Bill 2024/2025, which sought to introduce new taxes to meet fiscal targets under the IMF program, became a flashpoint, leading to widespread protests and fatal clashes, ultimately forcing the government to withdraw the bill. These protests, largely driven by the Gen-Z demographic, reflect broader issues of governance, corruption, and public expenditure management. There are growing calls for the government to focus more on reducing wastage and corruption rather than increasing taxes, highlighting the public’s demand for more responsible and transparent governance.

Kenya’s economic challenges are multifaceted, with high debt levels and public debt nearing 70% of GDP. While the IMF’s involvement is seen as crucial for maintaining financial stability, its prescriptions are often viewed as disproportionately affecting the poor and middle class. President William Ruto’s government is in a difficult position, needing to balance the IMF’s demands with public discontent. Following the protests, Ruto had to assure both the IMF and his citizens that Kenya would still meet its fiscal goals through alternative means, such as budget cuts and increased borrowing. This situation underscores the complex dynamics between national policies and international financial institutions’ requirements. The IMF’s influence in Kenya has become a rallying point for various social and political movements, with many feeling that its programs benefit financial stability at the cost of social stability and public welfare. Protesters see the IMF as an external force imposing harsh economic policies without fully understanding the local context and hardships faced by ordinary Kenyans, echoing a broader critique of the IMF’s role in developing countries. This sentiment underscores the need for sustainable economic growth that maintains social harmony and effectively addresses public grievances.

References:

The National Treasury and Economic Planning KENYA-IMF PROGRAM

International Monetary Fund IMF Statement on Kenya

Kenya’s Electoral Reforms: President Ruto Signs IEBC Amendment Bill

President William Ruto’s signing of the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) Amendment Bill, attended by his political rival Raila Odinga and Kalonzo Musyoka, marks a significant moment in Kenyan politics given their historically adversarial relationship. The bill, aimed at reconstituting the electoral commission, addresses long-standing issues within Kenya’s electoral system. It mandates the formation of a nine-member selection panel tasked with recruiting commissioners with proven expertise in ICT and accounting, expected to become operational by late October or early November 2024, ensuring a more structured and transparent recruitment process.

President Ruto assents to IEBC Bill

Reactions to the bill’s signing have been mixed, highlighting both support and skepticism. Raila Odinga emphasized the necessity of a unified electoral commission for credible future elections, viewing the bill’s focus on professional qualifications for commissioners as a positive step towards enhancing the commission’s efficiency. However, some public voices have expressed concerns about the implementation timeline and whether the changes will be sufficient to address entrenched electoral issues. This mix of reactions underscores the need for continuous monitoring and engagement from all stakeholders to ensure the new commission’s effectiveness.

The IEBC Amendment Bill represents a crucial step in Kenya’s electoral reforms, providing a framework for addressing systemic issues within the electoral commission. Ensuring the transparent and timely implementation of the new provisions is essential for maintaining public trust in the electoral process. Continuous public engagement and dialogue are necessary to build on this momentum, addressing underlying issues and ensuring a fair and credible environment for future elections. As Kenya moves forward, it is imperative that all stakeholders work together to support the new commission and uphold the integrity of the electoral system.

References:

Tuko Kenyans React as Raila Odinga Joins William Ruto during Signing of IEBC Amendment Bill: “Good Move”

The Star Raila, Kalonzo join Ruto as he assents to IEBC Bill

Nation Ruto assents to IEBC Bill, paves way for hiring of commissioners

Business Daily Stage set for fresh IEBC team as Ruto assents to Bill

The Africa Report Kenya to reconstitute electoral commission as Ruto signs IEBC bill into law







Gen Z Across East Africa: Unstoppable Force for Change and Justice

In the vibrant tapestry of East African protests, Kenyan Gen Z stands out with their digital flair and viral creativity. Imagine a protest powered by clever memes, hashtags like #Reject and #Occupy, and instant crowdfunding campaigns that raise millions in mere hours. Kenyan Gen Z activists have turned protests into digital movements, leveraging social media platforms to coordinate, communicate, and create a global buzz. They turned tragic moments into powerful calls for justice, uniting under the spirit of “the revolution will be live-streamed, hashtagged, and possibly even set to an AI-generated soundtrack”​ (Techweez)​​ (Amnesty International)​.

Children depicting protests

Contrast this with Uganda, where the dynamics of protest are considerably different due to a more repressive political climate. While Kenyan Gen Z activists use digital platforms to orchestrate protests and raise awareness rapidly, their Ugandan counterparts face a more formidable challenge. In Uganda, the government has a tight grip on internet access, frequently resorting to social media blackouts during periods of unrest, making it difficult for activists to communicate and organize efficiently online. Furthermore, Uganda’s Public Order Management Act imposes stringent restrictions on public gatherings, requiring protest organizers to seek police approval, which is often denied or delayed. This legal hurdle significantly stifles spontaneous and large-scale mobilizations that Kenyan Gen Z finds easier to execute​ (Techweez)​​ (Amnesty International)​. The Ugandan Gen Z is also up against a history of severe crackdowns on dissent. Reports of police brutality and extrajudicial killings are not uncommon, with Amnesty International documenting numerous cases of enforced disappearances and unlawful detentions​ (Amnesty International)​. For example, during the 2021 elections, opposition figures and their supporters faced intense repression, with security forces using excessive force to disperse crowds and detain activists arbitrarily. The physical risks associated with protesting in Uganda are therefore much higher, deterring many from participating in public demonstrations. Despite these challenges, Ugandan youth have found innovative ways to voice their dissent, such as through music, art, and satire, highlighting their resilience and creativity in navigating a restrictive environment.

Yet, the core message remains powerful and universal: “An idea whose time has come cannot be stopped even by military artillery.” Whether through the immediacy of a tweet in Nairobi or the grassroots resilience in Kampala, Gen Z across East Africa is proving that the demand for justice and accountability transcends borders and methods. Their innovative spirit and unyielding courage highlight a new era of activism, where the youth, armed with smartphones and a shared sense of purpose, are an unstoppable force for change.

References:

Aljazeera How Kenya’s protesters faced death to hold their leaders to account

Monitor Daring us to copy Kenyan Gen Z demos is a tall order

Cryptocurrency Security: Persistent Threats and Measures for Continuous Improvement

Crypto hacking incidents have shown fluctuating trends in 2024. Early in the year, a report revealed that hackers stole $1.7 billion in 2023, highlighting the growing threat. The RegTech Times reported that in Q1 2024, losses dropped by 23% compared to the same period in 2023, with total losses amounting to $336.3 million. Despite this reduction, crypto hacking still accounted for 96% of all incidents, reflecting the ongoing security challenges in the cryptocurrency industry. In February alone, over $67 million was stolen in 12 attacks on DeFi platforms, showcasing the sector’s vulnerability due to its decentralised nature and complex security needs.

10 Tampa Bay News Report

The first half of 2024 saw a significant rise in crypto thefts, with $1.4 billion stolen by hackers, according to a July 5 Reuters report. This sharp increase was attributed to sophisticated hacking techniques targeting digital assets. On the same day, Punch Nigeria reported data from DeFiLlama indicating that $664 million was stolen from crypto investors in the first six months of 2024. Chainalysis further highlighted that, despite enhanced security measures, substantial funds were still being stolen, underscoring the persistent threat to the cryptocurrency ecosystem. DeFi, or decentralised finance, platforms are blockchain-based systems that offer financial services without traditional intermediaries like banks. These platforms enable activities such as lending, borrowing, and trading through smart contracts, which are self-executing contracts with the terms directly written into code. The consistent targeting of DeFi platforms, with major breaches including $32.5 million from Playdapp and $26.1 million from Fixedfloat, emphasised the need for improved defenses.

These incidents underscore the critical need for continuous improvement in cybersecurity measures within the cryptocurrency sector. While there has been some success in reducing overall losses, the sophistication of attacks and the particular vulnerability of DeFi platforms remain significant challenges. The industry must evolve its security protocols, foster greater collaboration among stakeholders, and enhance user education to better protect against these persistent threats. The resilience of the cryptocurrency market will depend on its ability to adapt and fortify against an ever-evolving landscape of cyber threats.

References:

Reuters Crypto hacking thefts double to $1.4 bln in first half of 2024, researchers say

Punch Hackers steal $664m from crypto investors in six months – DefiLlama

Chainalysis Funds Stolen from Crypto Platforms Fall More Than 50% in 2023, but Hacking Remains a Significant Threat as Number of Incidents Rises
Reuters Crypto hackers stole around $1.7 bln in 2023 – report

RegTech Times Crypto Hacking Report for Q1 2024: Insights and Trends on declining incidents












Raila Odinga’s Ambitious Bid for African Union Commission Chairperson

Raila Odinga, a veteran Kenyan politician and leader of the opposition, has set his sights on the prestigious position of African Union Commission (AUC) Chairperson. However, his bid faces significant hurdles due to proposed changes in the AU’s election rules. These new regulations, which aim to introduce stricter eligibility criteria, could potentially disqualify Odinga from the race. Despite this, Odinga’s ambition remains undeterred as he seeks to navigate these challenges with the support of the Kenyan government.

Raila Odinga

The Kenyan government, under the leadership of President William Ruto, has publicly endorsed Odinga’s candidacy. A campaign secretariat has been established to bolster his bid, reflecting a rare moment of cooperation between the two political adversaries. Nevertheless, internal coordination issues have led to delays in the formal submission of Odinga’s application. By June 30, 2024, the government had yet to submit his bid, raising concerns about their commitment and the potential impact on Odinga’s chances. The deadline for submission is fast approaching, with the government racing against time to ensure that all necessary documentation is filed by August 6, 2024. This delay has amplified anxieties about the effectiveness of the campaign and whether the bid will meet the stringent new criteria set by the AU.

In parallel with addressing submission delays, diplomatic efforts are in full swing to garner support for Odinga’s candidature across the African continent. Kenyan envoys have been actively lobbying for endorsements from other member states, emphasizing Odinga’s extensive experience and commitment to African unity. Domestically, Odinga has shown his political acumen by responding supportively to recent Gen Z demonstrations, while simultaneously criticizing the government’s heavy-handed response to these protests. He condemned the administration’s approach, aligning himself with the youth movements and advocating for more progressive policies. The outcome of these efforts remains uncertain, with the next few weeks being crucial for Odinga’s campaign. If successful, Odinga could leverage his political acumen and regional backing to secure the AUC Chairperson position. However, failure to meet the AU’s new eligibility criteria or the submission deadline could result in disqualification, significantly impacting his political trajectory.

References:

The Star Why Raila’s bid for AUC top job is yet to be submitted – PS Sing’oei
Nation State in race against time to officially nominate Raila for AUC post

Kenya News Agency Envoys Urged To Popularize Raila Odinga’s AU Bid
The Kenya Times EXPLAINED: New AU Changes That Could Lock Out Raila from Race

The Nairobi Law Monthly Govt yet to submit Odinga name for AUC position

The EastAfrican Kenya to submit Raila’s AUC candidature by June 30








Addressing Unrest in Kenya: Youth Engagement and Reforms

In recent weeks, Kenya has experienced a surge in protests predominantly led by Generation Z, who are voicing their dissatisfaction with the Finance Bill 2024 and broader governance issues. Initially peaceful, these demonstrations have been disrupted by violent infiltrations, leading to looting and confrontations with the police. President William Ruto has acknowledged the grievances of the youth and expressed a willingness to engage in dialogue, while emphasizing the need to maintain public order. Human rights organizations have criticized the government’s response, highlighting the need for accountability and a more nuanced approach to managing protests. These organizations argue that peaceful demonstrators should not be conflated with criminal elements who exploit the situation for personal gain.

Gen Z protestors barricade road in Nairobi

The Kenyan protests contrast sharply with the Arab Spring demonstrations, which were characterized by widespread, often leaderless uprisings against autocratic regimes across the Middle East and North Africa. The Arab Spring saw governments toppled and significant political upheaval, driven by a combination of economic despair, political repression, and a desire for democratic reforms. In contrast, the Kenyan protests are more structured, with specific economic and social grievances articulated by the youth. While the Arab Spring often faced violent crackdowns, the Kenyan government’s approach has been to engage in dialogue and propose reforms, although incidents of police brutality have been reported. This approach underscores the Kenyan administration’s recognition of the legitimacy of the protesters’ demands, even as it grapples with maintaining public order.

To address the current unrest effectively, it is essential for the Kenyan government to establish a structured dialogue platform with youth leaders. This platform should facilitate regular consultations to address grievances and co-create solutions. Reassessing the Finance Bill 2024 in collaboration with economic experts and community representatives could help address the underlying economic concerns driving the protests. Comprehensive police reforms are also necessary to ensure law enforcement operates with greater accountability and respect for human rights. Effective public communication strategies are vital to fostering transparency and understanding between the government and the populace. Supporting peaceful protests by providing security and preventing infiltration by criminal elements is essential to safeguarding the rights of demonstrators and maintaining public order. These measures, aligned with studies on youth demonstrations’ impact on political change in Africa, can help Kenya navigate this period of unrest constructively and restore trust between the government and its citizens.

References:

The Star Leaders condemn infiltration of Gen Z protests by goons

France24 Kenyan police arrest hundreds accused of looting during anti-government protests

Citizen Digital ‘Ragtag Militia Infiltrating Peaceful Protests,’ Gideon Moi Condemns Violence In Protests

Lethal Repression of Peaceful Protest in Africa. Why Do (non-) Accountable and Military Regimes Shoot By Torsten Mix, Master’s in International Security (Downloadable dissertation paper)

Accord Youth Demonstrations and their Impact on Political Change and Development in Africa

AllAfrica Kenya: Youths March in Tribute to Anti-Budget Protest Victims in Nairobi

Revolutionizing Healthcare Funding: SHIF vs. NHIF in Kenya

The Social Health Insurance Fund (SHIF) is being introduced to replace the National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF) to enhance universal healthcare in Kenya. The initiative is aiming to address inefficiencies in NHIF by offering broader coverage and improved services.

It has been a long road to this point whereby previous attempts to introduce the SHIF have been met with significant resistance from healthcare practitioners and legislators concerned about the system’s readiness and financial burden on contributors. Legal challenges have also hampered the process questioning the mandatory contributions and rapid implementation timeline.

SHIF Registration to begin on 1st July, 2024

Scheduled for July 1st 2024, the planned rollout has so far encountered ICT system related difficulties pointing to possible inadequacies thus has led to a likelihood of postponement and continued reliance on NHIF. This latest development has caused confusion and uncertainty about the transition process. Many citizens are unclear about SHIF’s benefits and practical differences from NHIF. That notwithstanding, the government has assured Kenyans that the registration process will be straightforward, with citizens required to register at local centres or online. Registration will be free of charge and migration of existing NHIF members will be automatic, whereby members will confirm and update their details.

SHIF aims to revolutionise healthcare funding in Kenya. Despite resistance, legal challenges and operational issues, the ongoing efforts by the Ministry of Health are focused on addressing system readiness and stakeholder concerns to achieve efficient healthcare coverage.

References:

The Star Explainer: Difference between NHIF and SHIF

The Star Kenyans to register afresh for universal healthcare

Citizen Digital Kenyans to begin contributing to SHIF in July 2024

Business Daily SHIF transition team wants July 1 rollout plan suspended